# Sumner Welles, Churchill and the 1940 Drunkenness Allegation

- Original post: https://www.twitter.com/i/status/1990186126691459088
- Source account: [@irvingbooks](https://x.com/irvingbooks)
- Source language: English
- Duration: 4:05
- Published: 2026-08-24
- Canonical URL: https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation

## Transcript

[0:00](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation) You see, Sumner Welles, who was the deputy undersecretary of state here in the United States in 1940, Sumner Welles visited Europe in March 1940 to make a desperate attempt to get peace.

[0:10](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=10) He visited Hitler, he visited Mussolini, he visited Chamberlain, he visited their undersecretaries, and he visited Winston Churchill.

[0:17](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=17) March the 12th, 1940, he found Winston Churchill blind drunk behind the boardroom table in the Admiralty with an empty bottle of whiskey on the table, and Sumner Welles wrote in his report, 12 pages long.

[0:26](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=26) He began the report by saying, "Winston Churchill received me in a state of complete intoxication, a bottle of whiskey empty at the side of him on the table, incoherent, unable to speak." And at the end of the 12 pages, he then writes, "By this time, 90 minutes had passed, and Winston Churchill had become somewhat more

[0:39](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=39) sober." A scandalous state of affairs, you might think, for somebody with the lives of tens of thousands of British sailors in his, in his hands, Winston Churchill.

[0:46](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=46) But more serious was the fact that Sumner Welles went back to America and told everybody what he had seen.

[0:52](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=52) There was a side result, I write, of the Sumner Welles meeting with Churchill that did great harm. Welles put it about official Washington the famous Englishman was an alcoholic. He told Ickes that Churchill was a drunken bum.

[1:03](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=63) He told Burleigh, that's Adolf Burleigh of the State Department, that he'd found the First Lord of the Admiralty quite drunk.

[1:08](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=68) He was explicit about it in his report to Roosevelt, which I just mentioned.

[1:12](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=72) The latter passed it around North America.

[1:14](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=74) Roosevelt regretted to the visiting prime minister of Canada that Winston seemed to be drinking too much. He amplified this a few days later to the remark that Churchill is tight most of the time.

[1:24](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=84) "This is shameful," wrote Prime Minister Mackenzie King, the Canadian prime minister, scandalized in his diary.

[1:29](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=89) "This is shameful that he should have been in this condition when Sumner Welles went to see him. It's that arrogance and the assumed sup-" There's nothing wrong with arrogance. I've always said that it's aro- being arrogant that makes us British great, of course. We go to great expense and trouble to make our children

[1:41](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=101) arrogant. If we send our children to Eton and they came back without arrogance, we demand a refund, I think. That isn't, that isn't what exactly what the complaint was against Churchill. The complaint was that he was drunk.

[1:51](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=111) If you go to the archives and you get out the volumes of the Foreign Relations of the United States, which are the publications by the US Government Printing Office of the State Department papers, you'll find Sumner Welles' report,

[2:01](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=121) this diplomat's report on his visit with Churchill, and not a mention of Churchill's drunkenness.

[2:05](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=125) It's been cut out. But if you go to the Roosevelt Archives in Hyde Parks in New York State, you'll find Roosevelt's report from Sumner Welles, the original document Sumner Welles signed with those sentences included.

[2:17](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=137) This is why I never use published volumes.

[2:19](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=139) I never use diaries that have been printed somewhere else.

[2:22](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=142) I never use the printed volumes of documents because you can be absolutely certain that the bits that are vital to an understanding of history have been cut out.

[2:31](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=151) If you look in the British Cabinet Minutes, for example, even if you go into the archives in Britain, you'll find this.

[2:35](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=155) If you go into the, look in the British Cabinet Minutes in 1940, June 1940, you'll find important paragraphs have been blanked out.

[2:43](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=163) You're not given the original Cabinet Minutes, and there's a 30-year rule operating in England which says we can see all documents over 30 years old.

[2:49](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=169) If you see the war Cabinet Minutes, you find that certain paragraphs have been blanked out in the photocopies so you can't read them.

[2:55](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=175) And it's only when you go and look in the private diaries of people like Lord Halifax, the foreign secretary, or Lord Beaverbrook, or Neville Chamberlain, the former prime minister, that you find out what Churchill was saying that afternoon. I've quoted it here in this book,

[3:06](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=186) and you'll find it's interesting that when Adolf Hitler made his great peace plan in the summer of 1940, Winston Churchill in cabinet said, "I think that we would be wrong not to accept Mr. Hitler's peace offer."

[3:17](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=197) It's not just David Irving saying it. In other words, Winston Churchill himself said it in that cabinet meeting, which is why it's been blanked out so we can't read it, because it's embarrassing for us to have to admit now to anyone who can find the original w- quotations by Churchill or

[3:29](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=209) Lord Halifax's diary that we could have got out of the war in 1940 with the British Empire intact.

[3:34](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=214) If the war had ended in 1940, how many of those 6 million, or whatever figure you say is the right one, would have died?

[3:40](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=220) Because all of them, whoever died, however many it was, from 1940 onwards, they all died in that period from 1940 onwards. If the war had ended, the other Holocaust, Mr. Churchill's Holocaust, if that had ended in 1940 in June,

[3:54](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/J399Fb89iF0U/en/sumner-welles-churchill-and-the-1940-drunkenness-allegation?t=234) the killing of millions of innocent people, whatever side, German, French, Poles, Belgians, Hungarians, the bombing war, the extermination of minorities, whatever it was, wouldn't have taken place.
