# Debate Over Netanyahu’s Ancestry and Claims to the Land

- Original post: https://www.twitter.com/i/status/2122223643660841075
- Source account: [@voiceofrabbis](https://x.com/voiceofrabbis)
- Source language: English
- Duration: 2:27
- Published: 2026-11-17
- Canonical URL: https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land

## Transcript

[0:01](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=1) They have connection to this land- How? ... historically, biblically.

[0:06](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=6) Do they? Yes, they do. If, if, if Bibi's family, we know they lived in Eastern Europe.

[0:12](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=12) There's no evidence they ever lived here.

[0:14](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=14) He's not religious. But ancestrally- In what sense does- But ancestrally- How do we know that?

[0:17](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=17) Do you have his family tree? No, we don't. Do you?

[0:20](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=20) He doesn't. So no one does. That's the point. But if there is- So how do we know that he has any connection to this land at all?

[0:25](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=25) And if there has been a practice of Judaism and a connection to the language, the Bible, the land- His, his ancestors didn't.

[0:33](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=33) He doesn't practice Judaism in any rigorous way.

[0:36](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=36) His ancestors didn't live here, they didn't speak the language, and there's no evidence they ever lived here.

[0:40](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=40) So on what basis does he have a right to be here?

[0:41](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=41) Very much speaks the language. He has fought for the land.

[0:45](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=45) His family has fought for the land. I feel like you're dodging a very obvious question, which is, where does this right come from?

[0:50](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=50) And the reason it's meaningful- I've given you that answer ... is because there are a lot of people in the territory that Israel controls today, particularly in the West Bank- Mm-hmm ... who, through genetic testing, we can know their families have been here for thousands of years.

[1:05](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=65) We don't know whether they practiced Judaism, whether they were Samaritans, pre-Islam.

[1:10](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=70) We don't know that. A lot of them we know have been Christians for 2,000 years.

[1:15](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=75) They have less of a right to the land than someone whose ancestors, the only thing we know about them is they lived in Latvia or Poland. They're Eastern European.

[1:27](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=87) How does that work? They're Jewish. By what definition?

[1:31](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=91) They're Jewish by their- But how do we know they have any connection to the Jews of the Bible? ... ethnicity. They're Jewish by their faith.

[1:35](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=95) They're Jewish by the connection to the language, Jewish by the connection to the Torah.

[1:41](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=101) But, but, but how do we know that Bibi, specifically Bibi's ancestors ever lived here?

[1:46](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=106) How do we know that? I, I'm, I'm not sure if I understand your question.

[1:51](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=111) How do we know if the Prime Minister of Israel's ancestors ever lived- Maybe I could ask you, how do we know they didn't?

[1:59](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=119) I mean, there's- Well, it's on the basis of the claim that they did that all kinds of things happen.

[2:04](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=124) People are displaced, there's a money flow.

[2:07](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=127) I mean, there's, it's a big question. A lot hangs on this. Mm-hmm.

[2:09](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=129) It's not some theoretical thing like, "Ooh, you know, do my grandparents do this or do that?"

[2:13](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=133) It's like, "No, no, we have a right to be here because my ancestors were here."

[2:16](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=136) Okay, how do we know they were here?

[2:20](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/sD4C2mLArOwA/en/debate-over-netanyahu-s-ancestry-and-claims-to-the-land?t=140) I, I, I'm totally unable to process what you're trying to get at.
