# Ibn Kathir and Ahmad Shakir on Ruling by Man-Made Laws

- Original post: https://www.twitter.com/i/status/2122087365761990947
- Source account: [@AlDonFodio](https://x.com/AlDonFodio)
- Source language: Arabic
- Target language: English
- Duration: 9:43
- Published: 2026-11-16
- Machine translated. Check the original before quoting.
- Canonical URL: https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws
- Original-language version: https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/ar/%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%86-%D9%83%D8%AB%D9%8A%D8%B1-%D9%88%D8%A3%D8%AD%D9%85%D8%AF-%D8%B4%D8%A7%D9%83%D8%B1-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85-%D8%A8%D8%BA%D9%8A%D8%B1-%D9%85%D8%A7-%D8%A3%D9%86%D8%B2%D9%84-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%84%D9%87.md

## Transcript

[0:00](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws) Until Ibn Kathir said, “So this is the place where I say…”

[0:04](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=4) He said, “In all of this, every bit of it…”

[0:06](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=6) …is contrary to the laws God revealed. All of it is contrary to the laws of God.

[0:14](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=14) He revealed those laws to His servants, and revealed them to the prophets. They are contrary to them.

[0:22](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=22) So whoever abandons, he said… the decisive law revealed to Muhammad ibn Abdullah, the Seal of the Prophets, whoever abandons the law, meaning the decisive, established one, that God revealed to the Prophet Muhammad, with whom prophethood was sealed,

[0:42](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=42) and seeks judgment from something else, and turns to another judgment for good, from among the abrogated laws, and abandons the law of our Prophet, for the laws that were abrogated before, and seeks judgment from them, he has disbelieved.

[0:57](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=57) So what, he said, would be the case with one who seeks judgment from the Yasa…

[1:02](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=62) Whoever says, “I’ll judge by this Torah that the Jews follow, and by the Gospel,” and abandons the Prophet Muhammad’s law, becomes an unbeliever.

[1:09](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=69) What do you think, he said, of someone who goes to judgment by the Yasiq, and puts it ahead of the Prophet Muhammad’s law?

[1:18](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=78) For God’s sake, someone who sets the Sharia aside, while people keep saying, “The Sharia, the Sharia,” and puts in its place a law he has brought, has he put it ahead of the Sharia or not?

[1:31](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=91) What would putting it ahead mean? Nothing else.

[1:34](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=94) And he puts it ahead, when he says, “and puts it ahead of it,” this thing he abandoned, this thing he chose, that is, if his tongue can even be kept safe from it.

[1:45](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=105) When Sharia says, “We can't judge by Sharia now,” and he tells us, “Leave us alone,” then it was abandoned.

[1:52](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=112) Or perhaps he sees the Sharia itself as…

[1:54](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=114) Those stones now, I mean— Now, I mean, we're not going to stone a living person. He says, “Leave us alone.”

[2:00](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=120) We put that man ahead of what the book says about the Sharia of the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him.

[2:07](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=127) Whoever thinks religion is good for them, good, right, the religion's truth.

[2:11](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=131) He understood it. “And put it ahead of him”—he put it ahead. “Whoever does that,” whoever does that has disbelieved, by the consensus of the Muslims, he said.

[2:20](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=140) Whoever does that has disbelieved, he said, by Muslim consensus.

[2:23](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=143) Allah says, “Do they seek the judgment of ignorance,” and who judges better than Allah for those who are certain?

[2:31](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=151) Ibn Kathir said this about it. What did he say about these laws? Ahmed Shaker is a man— he is a great hadith scholar, a well-known man, a famous, well-known man.

[2:43](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=163) In his book Al-Hukm Al-Jahiliyyah, on page one hundred and eighty-nine, he said: “The matter with these man-made laws…”

[2:52](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=172) He discusses a chapter, just one chapter. It discusses…

[2:55](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=175) And what is that chapter? It discusses man-made laws.

[3:00](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=180) “Ruling by other than what Allah has revealed” is a broad topic.

[3:05](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=185) Laws, meaning the application of man-made laws, is one chapter he mentioned.

[3:10](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=190) Now he discusses that chapter on its own.

[3:13](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=193) So, its general and specific meanings, mixing the two together is a problem.

[3:18](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=198) He said: “The matter of these man-made laws…”

[3:22](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=202) “Their status is clear,” he said. “It is plain.”

[3:25](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=205) “It is as clear as the sun,” he said. “It is plainly evident.”

[3:29](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=209) “It is manifest disbelief,” he said. “Clear disbelief.”

[3:33](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=213) “There is no ambiguity about it, nothing hidden in it.”

[3:37](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=217) “And there is no evasion, no way around it.”

[3:42](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=222) “And there is no evasion,” “and no excuse for anyone who claims to be Muslim,” “whoever they may be, to act according to them or submit to them,” “or approve of them.” He said there is no excuse.

[3:54](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=234) Any Muslim claiming affiliation with Islam, whoever they may be, who acts according to this, and submits to the law out of respect, to the law out of respect.

[4:06](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=246) What honor? They take faith from you. They would never accept as honorable anything that conflicted with God's laws.

[4:13](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=253) Or its acknowledgment, or, that is, to acknowledge it, to affirm it.

[4:19](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=259) So let a person beware for their own sake, a person should be kind to themselves and be cautious, he said, everyone should be cautious for their own sake.

[4:31](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=271) He isn't talking about explicit disbelief.

[4:33](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=273) He's talking about man-made laws. And Shaykh Ahmed Muhammad Shaker wrote extensively about the people who dealt with this.

[4:40](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=280) Shaykh Ahmed Muhammad Shaker. Ahmed Shaker isn't a Kharijite, he's a well-known man, he authenticated the Musnad and many books, and he explained the Tirmidhi.

[4:51](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=291) He's also called a Qutbi and such, but he isn't that either.

[4:55](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=295) Oh, Sayyid Qutb was more knowledgeable than him, I mean, he was a scholar, a scholar among scholars, and Sayyid Qutb was what you would have been, if you were him.

[5:05](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=305) No, we don't want to go around discussing this.

[5:10](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=310) Shaykh Ahmed Muhammad Shaker said that. An excuse, of course. We were bound by the times.

[5:16](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=316) If this person is ignorant of what is happening, happening, happening, then later, some people may come Sayyid Ibn Uthaymeen was telling him that a kind of ignorance could befall him, befall them, he isn't told about that.

[5:29](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=329) An individual ruling of disbelief always requires establishing the conditions and removing the impediments.

[5:35](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=335) I'm saying, “So-and-so is an unbeliever,” twice, aren't I?

[5:38](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=338) But we're discussing this issue. Before you understand this issue, you haven't learned about unbelief, have you?

[5:46](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=346) All right. Shaykh Muhammad Ibrahim, That Mufti was a student of Shaykh Ibn Baz, he was a scholar.

[5:56](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=356) He has a book he wrote about Tahkeem al-Qawaneen.

[5:59](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=359) He wrote about this issue of laws. He said, “These courts are now two courts, something seen in many Muslim cities,” and in many of the cities of Islam, within them, they are prepared, completed, opened, with their doors wide open, opened,

[6:22](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=382) and people come to them in flocks, one flock after another.

[6:26](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=386) And when people go there in groups, their judges rule among them meaning, the rulers there, the judges, judge the people who come there by what contradicts the rulings of the Sunnah and the Book, what contradicts the Sunnah and the Book,

[6:45](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=405) from the rulings of that law, or its provisions, and they impose it on them, saying, “We have enforced it; it is binding on them.”

[6:52](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=412) And you approve of it for them, and make it binding upon them.

[6:59](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=419) All right, what disbelief could be greater than this disbelief What disbelief could surpass this disbelief?

[7:08](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=428) And what could contradict the testimony that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah more than this contradiction of the testimony, “Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah”?

[7:17](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=437) There can be no greater denial, no worse rejection than this.

[7:23](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=443) The Prophet is being pushed aside, when the Messenger was to govern life.

[7:27](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=447) The Book of Allah was meant to govern people’s lives.

[7:30](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=450) Yet they say, “No, take it to the mosque,” they say.

[7:34](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=454) When they speak of religion... If religion is only for the mosque, then what is it? They say, “Let’s debate.”

[7:42](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=462) Sheikh Muhammad Al-Amin Al-Shanqiti is also a great scholar, Adwa’ al-Bayan's author is Sheikh Al-Adbun Namir.

[7:49](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=469) That sheikh spoke of it much, and discussed these laws in many places, the ruling by laws.

[7:55](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=475) He discussed “and He shares His rule with no one.”

[8:00](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=480) He said, “And with these heavenly texts,” these texts that came down from heaven, from Allah, the exalted Allah whom we mentioned, it is utterly clear He said, “It is utterly clear.” that those—what is clear is that those who follow man-made laws the issue being discussed is man-made laws that is the point.

[8:29](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=509) The point at issue is not ruling by anything other than what Allah revealed in general.

[8:34](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=514) What we are discussing is man-made laws.

[8:37](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=517) If that person goes elsewhere, it's a problem.

[8:40](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=520) The etiquette of research and debate First of all, the subject being debated must be defined.

[8:45](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=525) All right. Then he said, “and He shares His rule with no one.”

[8:50](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=530) Then he mentioned this verse. He said that this makes it clear…

[8:53](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=533) that those who follow man-made laws, those who follow them, which Satan prescribed, through the tongues of his allies.

[9:00](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=540) He prescribed it. In violation of what God has prescribed, what God prescribed through His messengers, he prescribed in violation of it he has no doubt about their disbelief and their idolatry, and their idolatry, except for someone whose insight God has clouded,

[9:20](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=560) someone whose insight God has taken away, is the one who doubts, and blinded him to the light of revelation, like him, they too were blinded to the light of revelation by Him, that is the one who doubts.

[9:34](https://www.translate.mom/transcript/xyFt7bmKhhI5/en/ibn-kathir-and-ahmad-shakir-on-ruling-by-man-made-laws?t=574) Sheikh Muhammad Al-Amin Al-Shanqiti is not one of the Khawarij, and he is not our Qutb either. He is a scholar, a great scholar and imam.
