China's Dam Project and India's Response
China is building the world's largest dam,
and India is countering it. But
why are there protests over this in India?
So China, on the Brahmaputra
River, which in Tibet
is known as the Yarlung Tsangpo,
is building the world's biggest dam,
which it could weaponize against India
at any time by releasing huge amounts of water,
which could cause
devastating floods in India's northeast.
To counter this, the
Indian government has
also
fast- tracked an 11,000- megawatt
dam project on the same river
so that even if China releases
water upstream, this dam can
control it, or if China stops the water,
then from this dam's reservoir
those water needs can be met.
And protests against this
dam are currently underway
in Arunachal Pradesh,
in which the CBI has already [taken
action against] activist Bhanu Tatak
has been arrested because he received two
million rupees in funding from foreign NGOs
that are based in Ireland, the Philippines, and the UK.
Now think for yourself.
In India, this
dam is being built to counter whom?
China. So who would want to stop it?
Obviously, China. But you'll say the
funding is coming from here and there,
not from China.
That's the catch. Foreign funding always
comes through NGOs from here and there
so that no one can track the money trail.
And this is just one case.
In the Narmada Dam case, Medha Patkar,
because of whom the Narmada Dam
remained stalled for 30 years,
and now in the Great Nicobar
Island project, it's the same case.
So these aren't all
coincidences. That's why
I just hate protests,
because protests over genuine
issues do get started,
but they get hijacked to
destabilize any country. And
That's why the Indian government was
going to make the FCRA
rules much stricter.
But then the CJB protest happens.
I didn't say anything.
The rest, you understand.
You're smart enough to figure it out yourself.
End of transcript · 321 words · machine translated
Original transcript (Hindi)
China world का सबसे बड़ा dam बना रहा है और India इसको counter कर रहा है। पर इस पर protest क्यों हो रहे हैं India में? तो China, Brahmaputra river पर जिसको Tibet में
Yarlung Tsangpo के नाम से जानते हैं, उस पर world का biggest dam बना रहा है, जिसको वो India के against weaponize कर सकता है कभी भी बहुत ज्यादा पानी छोड़कर जिससे India के northeast में
devastating floods आ सकते हैं। इसको counter करने के लिए Indian government ने भी एक same river पर eleven thousand megawatt
के dam project को fast track कर दिया है ताकि अगर China ऊपर से पानी छोड़ भी दे तो ये dam उसको control कर पाए या फिर China अगर पानी रोक ले तो ये dam के reservoir से
वो पानी की needs fulfill हो पाए और इसी dam के against अरुणाचल प्रदेश में इस time protest चल रहे हैं, जिसमें CBI ने
already एक activist भानु टटक को arrest कर दिया है क्योंकि उसको बीस लाख funding आई थी foreign NGOs से जो Ireland, Philippines और UK based हैं। अब खुद सोचो
India में ये dam किसको counter करने के लिए बन रहा है? China. तो इसको रुकवाना कौन चाहेगा? Obviously China. पर आप कहोगे कि funding तो इधर-उधर से आ रही
है, China से थोड़ी आ रही है। तो यही तो catch है कि foreign funding हमेशा इधर-उधर से NGOs के through आती है ताकि कोई money trail को track ना कर पाए। और ये तो सिर्फ
एक case है। नर्मदा dam में मेधा पाटकर, जिसकी वजह से नर्मदा dam तीस सालों तक अटका रहा और अब Great Nicobar Island project में भी same case
है। तो ये सब coincidences नहीं होते हैं। इसलिए I just hate protests क्योंकि genuine issues की protest तो start हो जाती हैं,
पर उनको hijack कर लिया जाता है किसी भी country को destabilize करने के लिए। और इसीलिए Indian government FCRA rules को भी बहुत ज्यादा strict बनाने वाली
थी। पर तभी हो जाती है CJB protest। मैंने कुछ नहीं कहा। बाकी आप खुद समझदार हैं।