Discussion on Religious Practices and Community

Therefore, applying this Hadith to these

congregations that take place today is actually burdening the

Hadith with what it cannot bear.

The clearest thing is to note the donor and the recipient,

this does not exist in these congregations because they...

are all performing an obligatory prayer, whereas there,

one was performing an obligatory prayer,

the Imam, and the other a voluntary one, the recipient.

Therefore, citing this Hadith as evidence, as Al- Shafi'i and others say,

is that whoever has prayed the obligatory prayer in congregation,

then attends another congregation,

can they repeat that prayer with the other, legitimate congregation?

They said yes, and this is the evidence.