Transcript · English → Chinese
English → Chinese transcript
我是说我觉得这里发生的
情况是皮尔斯美国和以色列认为
我们可以很快取得一次
果断的胜利要么是斩首
这个政权要么是某种形式
的“震慑与打击”行动在战争
的最初几天就完成然后伊朗人
就会举手投降接受我们的要求
而且事实
上特朗普总统也说过有人告诉
他伊朗人很有可能会关闭霍尔木
兹海峡但他无视了那个警告
因为他认为我们会在这成为伊朗
可行选项之前就赢得胜利但现在
发生的情况是我们并没能
取得快速而果断的胜利而且我们
现在陷入了一场持久战一场
消耗战而且那正是一场
伊朗人早就做好准备的
战争而且那一场伊朗人
非常有望在其中取胜的战争如果
你想一想在升级阶梯上的各个
步骤我们能够采取的措施你会
看到伊朗
人在各个方面都能与
我们相匹敌,并且他们可以导致
不仅给该地区的各国带来巨大的
破坏以及驻扎在那里的美国军事
力量造成巨大的损失甚至
可能会更重要的是对国际经济
的影响。随着你在升级
阶梯上走得越高他们
就有能力拖垮国际经济。
这将是灾难性的。
所以我们现在处在这样一种
局势中既未能取得迅速而决定
性的胜利,又有可能以一种
非常严重的方式失败。所以如果
你要给唐纳德·特朗普
出主意而这我得说是在
可能性光谱的极不靠谱一端
期望阶梯,但如果是你,
你会给他什么建议?
你会给他什么建议?
很明显,我觉得他是想摆脱这
件事的,但他似乎并不太清楚
自己要怎么做,才不会看起来
像是一次彻底的失败或溃退。
你会建议他怎么做,
才既高明又切实可行,
能把美国从这场战争中抽
身出来?关于这个问题我
认真思考了很久,而且我也
和许多非常聪明的人谈过,
还有一些我会称之为“公关高手”
的朋友。他们几乎总能想
出办法,把人从烂摊子里
解救出来。而我不认为
这件事会有谁能提出一个很好的
解决方案。大多数人的
看法是,特朗普总统应该
宣布胜利,然后撤出。
我的意思是,他
当然可以这么做,
但这会被视为这会被视为
美国遭到一次屈辱性的失败。
而且,更进一步说,
你会遇到这样一个问题,
那就是伊朗人他们自己可能
也不会同意结束这场战争。
美国可以退出,
但是以色列人和伊朗人
可能会继续打下去。再说一次,
正如我之前讲的,伊朗人手里有
很多牌可打。他们可以造成
很大的破坏。所以即便我们
抽身而退,也并不清楚
这样是否就能解决问题。
然后呢,回到我一开始说的,
美国看起来会像是遭受
了一次屈辱性的失败。
所以我觉得,特朗普总统
已经把自己置于一种境地,
在这种境地里,根本不存在
什么好的退场策略。
是的,我的看法就是这样。
而且我到现在仍然完全想不通,
在政治上,
先不说其他任何因素,
他为什么会认为这是他选择去下
最大一注的好
时机因为期中选举要到了这
是他做过的最大胆的一次。
你知道他本来就看起来好像
有可能失去众议院还可能因此
失去参议院然后那就几乎算完了
你知道作为总统如果你对国会的
任何一部分都没有控制权基
本上你也做
不了什
么。
End of transcript · 655 words · machine translated
Original transcript (English)
I mean, I think what's going on here, Piers, is that the United States and Israel thought that we could win a quick and decisive victory, either by decapitating the regime or some form of shock and awe campaign for the first few
days of the war. And the Iranians would then throw up their hands and they would submit to our demands. And in fact, President Trump has said that he was told that there was a good Strait of Hormuz, but he ignored that warning
because he thought we would win a victory before that became a viable option for the Iranians. But what's happened here is that we did not achieve a quick and decisive victory, and we're now in a long war, a war of attrition. And that's
a war that the Iranians prepared for, and that's a war that the Iranians are in an excellent position to prevail in. If you think about the various steps up the escalation ladder that we can take, what you see is that the Iranians
can match us at every point, and they can cause can match us at every point, and they can cause not only enormous damage for the countries in the region and for the United States military forces that are located there, but maybe even
forces that are located there, but maybe even They have the ability, as you go up the escalation They have the ability, as you go up the escalation ladder, to tank the international economy. This would be catastrophic. So we are now in a situation,
would be catastrophic. So we are now in a situation, having failed to achieve a quick and decisive victory, where we could lose in a really serious way. So if you were advising Donald Trump, which is, I have to say, at the unlikely end of the
is, I have to say, at the unlikely end of the expectation ladder, but if you were, what advice would you give him? He clearly, I think, wants to get out of this, but he doesn't seem to really know how he can
do that which doesn't look like a crushing defeat do that which doesn't look like a crushing defeat or retreat. What would you advise him to do which would be a skillful and achievable way of extricating America from this war?
I've thought long and hard about this, and I've I've thought long and hard about this, and I've talked to a number of very smart people, a number of my friends who are what I would call spinmeisters. They can figure out almost always how to get
out of a mess. And I don't think anybody can out of a mess. And I don't think anybody can come up with a good solution for solving this problem. What most people say is that what President Trump should do is declare victory and get out.
I mean, he can do that, but it will be seen I mean, he can do that, but it will be seen as a humiliating defeat for the United States. as a humiliating defeat for the United States. And furthermore, you run into the problem that
And furthermore, you run into the problem that the Iranians themselves might not agree to end the war. The United States can quit, but the the war. The United States can quit, but the Israelis and the Iranians may continue fighting.
Israelis and the Iranians may continue fighting. And again, as I said, the Iranians have a lot of cards to play here. They can do a lot of damage. So even if we walk away, it's not clear damage. So even if we walk away, it's not clear
that that solves the problem. And then again, where I started, the United States will look where I started, the United States will look like it suffered a humiliating defeat. So I think that President Trump has got himself into
think that President Trump has got himself into a situation where there is really no good exit strategy. Yeah, that's the way I see it. And strategy. Yeah, that's the way I see it. And I'm still completely baffled why, politically,
never mind anything else, he thought this was never mind anything else, he thought this was a good time to take the biggest gamble he's a good time to take the biggest gamble he's ever taken, because he's got the midterms coming.
ever taken, because he's got the midterms coming. You know, already he was looking like he might lose the House, he could lose the Senate over this. And then that's pretty much it. You know, as a president, if you don't have any control
as a president, if you don't have any control of any part of Congress, there's not much you