Transcript · Hindi → English
Analysis of Savarkar's Ideology and Masculinity
Did Savarkar write something like this, and if he did then in what context and why did he write
it?
Absolutely, he did. There is no doubt about it. Why did he write this?
Because Hindutva is a
toxic masculine ideology. You should read more of Savarkar's writings
where he says Hindu men should have protein-rich diets
so that they can become strong. There were so many wrestling arenas at the time where
there was this idea that Hindu men would go, and they would
literally learn how to build their bodies.
So this is a very toxic masculine ideology where
there is a huge emphasis on masculinity, and masculinity here
means that physically, you should have abs and so on.
And this was also because, again, this is from Savarkar,
because there was this idea that somehow Muslim men
are far more masculine
than Hindu men. It's a perceived insecurity. I don't know
why
It is. However, if I can trace this back, before this, the British
had also spoken about it. The British too were of the view that Hindu
architecture and Hindu men
are effeminate, right, and Muslim men and Muslim
architecture are masculine. That is why they adopted domes, arches, and so on.
And now, what we see in the North and South Blocks, what they built across New Delhi. Now,
it has changed considerably. In what Lutyens built, he incorporated Mughal
architecture. So they had this very interesting idea: we hate the
Mughals because, you know, there is the memory of the Crusades. But we also have this fear
of them because they inspire, you know, a lot of fear in us and all that. We
also want to become like them. The British did this because Hindutva, somewhere,
emerged in that very milieu. The British had a great deal of influence.
That's why this idea came about too. So, one aspect of masculinity
became that you have to have a strong build. Masculinity has a major influence.
The other is, how will you show your masculinity, right? By taking another
community's honor. It's a very old idea that women
represent a community's honor.
So, if you want to defame a community,
take their honor, then you must brutalize their women
right?
And that's why he said, "Brother, you should go ahead and rape."
You know, as a political tool.
Because this is again part of a very toxic masculine ideology that
this is what masculinity is, and how else do they show it?
So Savarkar did say this, and
Savarkar also had this idea somewhere, which has become very famous today.
And I think it has had the greatest impact
on the ideology of the RSS, etc., and their followers…
has an effect. The idea that the Muslims who came were a dark age
So you will see that the exact term has also been used in the newly created NCERT.
Before they talk about the Delhi Sultanate and the Mughals,
they have made a page in which they have called this a dark age, and they have
explained it. They have compared it with Nazi Germany and everything, which
is ridiculous
End of transcript · 529 words · machine translated
Original transcript (Hindi)
सावरकर ने क्या ऐसा लिखा है और लिखा अगर है तो किस context में और क्यों लिखा है? बिल्कुल लिखा है। There is no doubt about this क्यों लिखते हैं Because Hindutva is a toxic masculine ideology. आप सावरकर की और चीजें पढ़िए
जहां पर वो कहते हैं कि Hindu men should have a protein rich diet ताकि वो strong बन सके। उस समय कितने अखाड़ा थे जहां पर there was this idea कि Hindu men will go and they will learn body कैसे बनाते हैं literally तो यह बड़ा toxic masculine ideology है जहां
पर मर्दानगी पर बड़ा emphasis है and मर्दानगी का यहां मतलब यह है कि आप physically आपकी abs वगैरह हो and यह इसलिए भी था यह again this is from सावरकर because there was this idea that somehow Muslim men are far more masculine
than Hindu men. यह perceived insecurity है। मुझे नहीं पता यह क्यों है। हालांकि अगर If I can trace this back इससे पहले यह अंग्रेजों ने भी बात की थी। अंग्रेज भी they were of this idea that Hindu architecture Hindu men
are effeminate right and Muslim men and Muslim architecture is masculine इसीलिए फिर उन्होंने dome and arch वगैरह अपनाई और अब जो North South block में देखते हैं, जो उन्होंने पूरी नई दिल्ली बनाई। अब तो काफी change हो गई है। Lutyens जो उन्होंने बनाई उसमें उन्होंने Mughal architecture को रखा। So they had this very interesting we hate the
Mughals because you know Crusades की memory है। But we also have this of them because they inspire you know a lot of fear in us and all that हम उनकी तरह बनना भी चाहते हैं। अंग्रेजों ने किया because Hindutva कहीं ना कहीं उसी milieu में पैदा हुआ है। बड़ा ही influence रहा अंग्रेजों से तो इसीलिए यह idea भी आ गया। तो masculinity का एक
तो हो गया कि भाई you have to have a strong build। मर्दानगी का बड़ा influence है। The other is how will you show your मर्दानगी right दूसरी community का honor छीनकर तो यह तो बड़ी पुरानी बात है कि भाई औरतें represent community का honor। तो अगर आपको किसी community को बदनाम करना है,
उनकी honor लेनी है तो you must brutalize their women right और इसीलिए उन्होंने यह कहा कि भाई you should go ahead and rape you know as a political tool because this is again part of a very toxic masculine ideology कि
भाई यही तो होती है मर्दानगी और कैसे दिखाते हैं अपना। तो सावरकर ने यह बिल्कुल कहा था and सावरकर का यह idea भी था कहीं ना कहीं जो कि आज बड़ा famous होता है and I think वह सबसे ज्यादा RSS वगैरह और जो उनके followers हैं उसकी ideology को बड़ा
effect करता है। यह idea कि जो मुस्लिम लोग आए थे वह dark age थे तो आप देखेंगे exact term NCERT में भी use हुआ है जो नई बनी है। जहां पर before they talk about the Delhi Sultan and the Mughals उससे पहले उन्होंने एक page बनाया है जिसमें उन्होंने इसको dark age बोला है and they have explained they have compared it with the Nazi Germany and everything which
is ridiculous