EU Sanctions on RT Journalist Chey Bowes: Due Process and Free Speech
7 min About Russia Politics
7 min About Russia Politics
Yesterday, 30 individuals, from what I can tell, were sanctioned by the European Union for information manipulation.
One of those individuals was Chey Bowes, an Irish citizen who works for RT, Russia Today, which is an international, uh, media organ affiliated to the Russian state.
Now, these sanctions entail, um, an a- uh, uh, a f- that, that your assets are frozen, um, meaning that you cannot access, um, a bank, you cannot withdraw cash, you cannot use a credit card, um, and it also entails a travel ban in Europe.
Uh, in addition, um, other European, um, citizens are prohibited from assisting you financially.
So it's a kind of financial death, you might say, or an economic death.
The question is, uh, what is the basis for this kind of intervention?
What is the basis for these sanctions? Well, if we go to Council Decision, uh, 2024/2643 of the 8th October 2024, um, basically what that says is that one of the activities that could be targeted by sanctions is, quote, "Planning, directing, engaging in, directly or indirectly,
supporting, or otherwise facilitating the use of information manipulation and interference."
Okay? And the other condition is that it must be connected in some way to the Russian state. Okay?
And since, uh, Chey Bowes is, uh, works for RT, um, a Spanish, uh, I'm sorry, a Russian, uh, media outlet, it's obvious that, uh, he, uh, can be connected, his activity can be connected to the Russian state, um, and therefore, they, they feel they can justify the sanction.
But here's the thing.
Uh, w- when you, uh, target, uh, somebody with these kinds of sanctions and you turn their life upside down, you better have a damn good justification for it, uh, because you've bypassed basically all of the normal legal procedures.
There was no, um, let's say, charge pressed against him.
There was no, uh, kind of evidence presented, um, you know, i- in a court of law, no evidence presented to, um, this individual, uh, before his assets were froze- frozen.
Um, so his life was turned upside down without any, mm, recognizable due process.
And, uh, if you say to me he could appeal it after the fact, well, if you throw someone in prison in the dead of night and you tell them to call a lawyer, that's not rule of law.
That's not rule of law. Rule of law means we should have stable expectations about the p- the, the security of our property, about our ability to move around, um, and that a state or public authority cannot just, uh, swoop in and, uh, seize our assets,
um, uh, because some faceless official decided that we were a threat.
And when you look at the nature of this threat, the threat is essentially, um, s- spreading information that counter-- that undermines the official, um, narrative about the war.
That's what it is. If you actually scratch underneath the kind of jargon, um, threatening European democracy for an EU official is undermining the narrative about the war.
To target, um, speech in this way is particularly, uh, worrying, right? It's particularly worrying.
Um, if you just look at history, if you just look at how these counter-propaganda measures have been used in the past, these kind of information warfare, um, how it's been used against citizens.
Look at, say, it, it's quite, um, you know, chastening to look at something like, uh, the laws that were passed in Nazi Germany.
So let's look at the Law Against Treacherous Attacks on State and Party, which, uh, was from 20th December 1934.
Quote, "Whoever intentionally makes or spreads an untrue or grossly distorted assertion of fact that is liable to seriously harm the welfare of the Reich or the reputation of the Reich government or the National Socialist German Workers' Party or its organizations shall, unless the heavier penalties prescribed by other provisions,
be punished with imprisonment of up to two years, and if he makes or spreads the assertion publicly, with imprisonment of not less than three months."
So this kind of weapon, right, this kind of, mm, information weapon or let's say propaganda weapon, um, has been used in the past, okay?
And it's been used by very unsavory regimes.
And now, mm, we hear people cheering this on.
We hear people saying he was a stooge for Russia, he was working for Putin, he was in a Russia media, working for Russian media.
They're completely missing the point. You might not like what he says, you might not like the fact that he Rus- he works for Russian media, but that doesn't make him a criminal, and that certainly doesn't justify, uh, freezing his assets and preventing him from traveling in Europe,
um, without any hearing, without any presentation of evidence, without any, um, opportunity to face his accusers.
It's remarkable, and it's truly, I think, very disturbing what's happening here.
Europe is going down a very, very dark path, and, um, if we continue to suspend rule of law in this way, uh, based on unproven allegations that are not even charges, uh, if we take the administrative kind of, um, route of suspending assets without, uh, of freezing assets without actually presenting charges,
then, um, this is an extremely dangerous precedent.
And, uh, if it can happen to Chey Bowes, it can happen to you or me.
So let's not be naive about this. Um, when you break down a culture of rule of law, when you break down the institutions of rule of law, you are threatening all citizens everywhere.
All citizens, um, are affected by this, and we should all be speaking out against this.
End of transcript · 958 words
TranslateMom transcribes and translates videos from X, TikTok, YouTube and Instagram. Paste a link and you get a page like this one, in your language.