Manchester City Financial Breaches: Commission Findings and Appeal
4 min About United Kingdom
4 min About United Kingdom
We have some breaking news coming out of English football as the long-running legal battle between Manchester City and the Premier League took another significant turn Tuesday as the league published a redacted summary of an independent commission's findings against the club.
The sanctions phase and any potential appeals still to come.
The commissions found that Manchester City committed serious breaches of Premier League financial rules over a nine-season period, concluding the club used a series of sham sponsorships and commercial arrangements that artificially inflated revenue,
reduced reported costs, and misrepresented the club's financial position. According to the Premier League, those arrangements distorted the club's finances by more than 900 million pounds. The commission also found the club would have had and been in substantial breach of both Premier League and
UEFA financial regulations had its finances been reported accurately. Premier League CEO Richard Masters said the court decisions establishes the fact of what occurred at Manchester City between 2009 and 2018, adding that the findings showed the club systematically broke Premier League
rules for nearly a decade and called it the most significant disciplinary case in league history.
Manchester City said in a statement they're disappointed and surprised by the findings. They continue to deny the allegations and will appeal, arguing the investigation contains material errors of law, principle, and fact. Manchester City are expected to appeal and will have until October 2nd to do so.
After that, attention turns to separate sanctions hearing which will determine the punishment, though no timetable for that phase has yet been announced.
And here to break it more down, because this is a massive, massive story, is Premier League financial football correspondent and professor at University of Liverpool, Kieran Maguire.
Kieran, first and foremost, can you just break down the timeline of what has happened? Because since Friday, this is now big news upon big news.
Yes, on, on Friday we had a leak that Manchester City had allegedly been found guilty of all but one of the charges. That has now been confirmed by the Premier League statement. Um, and o- over a nine-year period, it's effectively stating that Manchester City has, um,
lied to the Premier League in terms of its financial statements, has lied to the auditors, uh, has effectively lied to players and coaches when they were being recruited, and has given itself a financial advantage of, uh, about 120 million bucks a year o- over the other clubs in the Premier League as a result of doing so.
Kieran, uh, the, the most incredible thing to me is for the 114 that we heard of the 115 initial charges, what's the most damning finding that we find from today's reports?
I think the damning finding is that, uh, senior management at Manchester City have deliberately concealed information, have conducted a huge fraud, uh, with the aim of misrepresenting the club's accounts to all of the authorities with the aim of achieving a competitive, uh, advantage.
And they've also, when you take a look at the commission reports, uh, it talks about witnesses giving false evidence, witnesses being unreliable, um, and all of these witnesses were coming from the Manchester City side.
So it, it is a, it's, it's a staggering statement because normally the- these commissions are quite reserved and conservative i- in, in the way that they would present comments.
But this is, uh, this is damning. I did speak to somebody in Manchester a few days ago who said at the time, "This is worse than the worst case scenario that had been envisaged by, by staff."
And this certainly appears to be the case.
End of transcript · 613 words
TranslateMom transcribes and translates videos from X, TikTok, YouTube and Instagram. Paste a link and you get a page like this one, in your language.