0:00

Those illegal immigrants, and they are illegal immigrants, are leaving a safe country, France. They're not fleeing danger, they're in France already.

0:07

Um, so I do agree it creates a massive pull factor. Yes.

0:11

Gentlemen, thank the shadow minister for giving way.

0:13

Has he considered for a moment why there are so many refugees globally? Why there are 70 million people without a home to call their own? What the effects of wars, environmental disaster, and human rights abuse has on populations around the world? Shouldn't there be an international

0:33

effort to try to help those people as well as dealing with the problems at home? Will putting up barbed wire all around the world solve the problem or create an even worse situation globally?

0:46

What I don't think will solve the problem is transferring tens, potentially tens of millions of people, he gave the number just then, it was 60 or 70 million. Trans- transferring tens of millions of people into the West, I don't think is the right solution to this problem.

0:59

Those people who are depl- displaced are probably better helped close to their country, uh, of origin. But transporting people on mass into this country, um, I don't think, um, is the solution to that.

1:10

And by the way, the people who are crossing by small boat are not the most vulnerable. They're not typically women and children.

1:16

They're not people who are sick and vulnerable.

1:18

They are mostly young men who are paying people smugglers.

1:21

And if we were gonna choose who to help, it wouldn't be mainly young men who are paying people smugglers. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, um, I'm gonna just make a little bit of progress. I will give way again, but I wanna make a bit of progress.

1:31

There'll be plenty of other opportunities-

End of transcript · 303 words

iPhone app Translate videos on your iPhone Paste a TikTok, Instagram or X link, add subtitles in your language and save the video to Photos.

Made with TranslateMom

TranslateMom transcribes and translates videos from X, TikTok, YouTube and Instagram. Paste a link and you get a page like this one, in your language.

Transcribed with TranslateMom. Paste any video link to get subtitles and a transcript in your language.

© 2026 TranslateMom · AI video translation and subtitles Transcripts Sources Pricing Legal