Debate Over Netanyahu’s Ancestry and Claims to the Land
2 min About Israel Politics
2 min About Israel Politics
They have connection to this land- How? ... historically, biblically.
Do they? Yes, they do. If, if, if Bibi's family, we know they lived in Eastern Europe.
There's no evidence they ever lived here.
He's not religious. But ancestrally- In what sense does- But ancestrally- How do we know that?
Do you have his family tree? No, we don't. Do you?
He doesn't. So no one does. That's the point. But if there is- So how do we know that he has any connection to this land at all?
And if there has been a practice of Judaism and a connection to the language, the Bible, the land- His, his ancestors didn't.
He doesn't practice Judaism in any rigorous way.
His ancestors didn't live here, they didn't speak the language, and there's no evidence they ever lived here.
So on what basis does he have a right to be here?
Very much speaks the language. He has fought for the land.
His family has fought for the land. I feel like you're dodging a very obvious question, which is, where does this right come from?
And the reason it's meaningful- I've given you that answer ... is because there are a lot of people in the territory that Israel controls today, particularly in the West Bank- Mm-hmm ... who, through genetic testing, we can know their families have been here for thousands of years.
We don't know whether they practiced Judaism, whether they were Samaritans, pre-Islam.
We don't know that. A lot of them we know have been Christians for 2,000 years.
They have less of a right to the land than someone whose ancestors, the only thing we know about them is they lived in Latvia or Poland. They're Eastern European.
How does that work? They're Jewish. By what definition?
They're Jewish by their- But how do we know they have any connection to the Jews of the Bible? ... ethnicity. They're Jewish by their faith.
They're Jewish by the connection to the language, Jewish by the connection to the Torah.
But, but, but how do we know that Bibi, specifically Bibi's ancestors ever lived here?
How do we know that? I, I'm, I'm not sure if I understand your question.
How do we know if the Prime Minister of Israel's ancestors ever lived- Maybe I could ask you, how do we know they didn't?
I mean, there's- Well, it's on the basis of the claim that they did that all kinds of things happen.
People are displaced, there's a money flow.
I mean, there's, it's a big question. A lot hangs on this. Mm-hmm.
It's not some theoretical thing like, "Ooh, you know, do my grandparents do this or do that?"
It's like, "No, no, we have a right to be here because my ancestors were here."
Okay, how do we know they were here?
I, I, I'm totally unable to process what you're trying to get at.
End of transcript · 489 words
TranslateMom transcribes and translates videos from X, TikTok, YouTube and Instagram. Paste a link and you get a page like this one, in your language.