0:01

Let me ask you a different question that relates though to what you said at, at the top of, of this last, um, soliloquy of sorts.

0:11

Sorry for rambling. No, no, no. Which was this? I've got it all pinned up.

0:14

You, you made, you made an observation, um, that corporations shouldn't be the ones making decisions.

0:20

Absolutely. The republic should be the ones making decisions. That's right.

0:24

So we're going to talk to Elon Musk a little bit later today.

0:27

Uh, and one of the, the great controversies of this moment, as it relates to Ukraine, as it happens, is about his decision, uh, to, um, slow down or not, uh, depending on what you believe has happened here, Starlink or Starshield or some version of both.

0:44

What do you think of that scenario?

0:47

So first of all, I like Elon. Like, I personally like the guy, so take it with a pound of salt.

0:53

Um, I think that when the republic needs to be in charge of these decisions, what that means is there are decisions that they need to make, and there are others that they do leave up to companies.

1:02

Who America sells weapons to, that's not up to me.

1:05

I'll go to prison if I make that decision for myself.

1:08

To what level a company is willing to put their civilian infrastructure at risk for another country's benefit, that is a question that is often not controlled by the government, at least not as of right now.

1:20

Again, let me give you a steel man on this.

1:22

Uh, Russia says that if, and they've, they've hinted this, I don't know- But a steel man's different than a straw man. Agreed.

1:28

Look, I'll, I'll, yeah, steel man, I'll give you the strongest possible argument. Okay.

1:32

Russia says, "I am going to destroy the Starlink constellation if you allow it to be used for offensive military activity against my country."

1:41

You can't, you cannot claim it's civilian infrastructure when you are explicitly allowing them with knowledge to use them in this way.

1:48

And the satellites, because they orbit the whole planet, the same ones that orbit the US are the ones that are orbiting Ukraine, right?

1:55

Because they're going in circles. So imagine this, Russia wipes out the constellation with electronic attack, kinetic attack, cyber effects, however they do it.

2:02

Um, so they say, "Great, we're going to do this."

2:04

And from a war- international law perspective, we are absolutely justified.

2:08

Nobody can claim that we are attacking civilian infrastructure.

2:10

We're attacking military infrastructure.

2:12

And should Elon have to say, "Well, okay, I will allow it to keep using it for offensive military action, and you can just destroy my entire global constellation because that's fighting for democracy."

2:26

And that's, that's what I think people don't realize the position he's in.

2:30

It can be a decision between those two things.

2:32

Do I stand up for democracy, and then by the way, ruin a lot of US war fighting capability that depends on those same satellites?

2:39

Or do you say, "You know what? I am going to take this region, and I'm going to, I'm going to limit the speeds that were being..."

2:43

And people are saying, "Oh, but there's, you know, there's defensive systems that use this."

2:47

Yes, I'm fully aware of that. Some of my systems use those exact same links.

2:51

But there are offensive weapons in Ukraine being used to attack Russia using civilian Starlink satellites.

2:57

So that, that is, that is a steel man, and I have not heard a very good argument for why Elon should sacrifice the existence of the entire Starlink network to, to prove a point about defending democracy, particularly given that it's not America.

3:11

If it were America, I would- Isn't that always going to be the risk though?

3:14

Meaning for, for any company that's going to have, um, a, a network, especially in space- Yes ... that the second you have that network in space, um, and depending on how it's being used- Yep ... that it becomes a military target.

3:27

It is not anything. So like, there, there are thing, there's, there's different degrees to which this is the case.

3:32

For example, this is the constant debate over whether a bridge, a civilian bridge, counts as a valid military target.

3:37

Does a power plant count? Like, what fraction of the power goes? Are there other options?

3:41

So it's not quite simple where if it's used in any way for military, it becomes a valid military target. It's, it's, it's a matter of degrees.

3:49

Um, but in this case, look, if the United States were telling SpaceX, "You need to do this," I think that they then have an obligation to help defend the constellation and also probably go to Russia and say, "Hey, you do that, we're going to glass you or some other terrible thing that you really don't want to happen."

4:09

I, I don't think it's reasonable for the government to basically outsource that responsibility to a corporate executive and say, "Hey, we're not going to tell you you have to do this, but, but we will be really angry if you don't do this thing that will get your whole constellation destroyed."

4:22

It, it seems untenable to me. Um, let me ask you a separate question because it has to do with- Actually, one last thing I should point out.

4:29

There are two networks. There's Star- Starlink- And Starshield.

4:32

And Starshield, which is owned and operated by the Department of Defense with assistance from SpaceX.

4:37

To be very clear, the United States could give access to Ukraine to the Starshield network and allow them to run all of their weapons off that.

4:45

And that is a military target. That, that's how it's supposed to be. But guess what?

4:48

The government doesn't want to give Ukraine access. You know why?

4:52

Because they know that then Russia will blow up Starshield and the US military won't have it. So you're in this position.

4:57

I can't believe I didn't make this point at the beginning.

5:00

The US government isn't even willing to stand up for Ukraine because they're afraid of losing their constellation.

5:05

Why should Elon have to lose the civilian network when the government of his own country is unwilling to put anything at risk for the same?

5:13

And this gets to a bigger problem, which is that nobody in the West actually wants Ukraine to win.

5:17

They just want them to not lose for as long as possible, which is a bizarre and absurd war fighting position.

5:22

But I'm not in charge. I don't get to make these decisions.

5:26

Um- And if you think you like my opinion on this one, wait till you find out my other opinions, and you'll be right back to being glad I'm not making these decisions for the country.

End of transcript · 1,148 words · machine translated

iPhone app Translate videos on your iPhone Paste a TikTok, Instagram or X link, add subtitles in your language and save the video to Photos.

Made with TranslateMom

TranslateMom transcribes and translates videos from X, TikTok, YouTube and Instagram. Paste a link and you get a page like this one, in your language.

Transcribed and translated with TranslateMom. Paste any video link to get subtitles and a transcript in your language.

© 2026 TranslateMom · AI video translation and subtitles Transcripts Sources Pricing Legal