Amazon Warehouse Workers vs. Software Engineers: A Debate on Equity
5 min Money & business
5 min Money & business
Like, I'm a software engineer, right? Yeah.
So if I went to Amazon as a software engineer, I would literally make 100,000 dollars more just in equity compensation.
But if I took my same resume, my same skills, my same work ethic, and I went to Amazon as a warehouse worker, zero equity. I get 0 dollars in equity, and I work probably harder doing 10-hour days on the warehouse floor with, like, two 15-minute breaks and constant surveillance.
Okay. So would you prefer- So how is that fair?
Why am I not getting equity in my work? So let's go back to the, um, coffee shop analogy.
You don't like the Amazon one, do you? No, I like Amazon too. Okay.
I mean, the point is, if they couldn't get any workers in the warehouse, they would change the compensation until they got workers in the warehouse.
But doesn't that seem like a flaw in our economy- No, no, no, no. It's the market- ... that people are compensated differently when they work hard?
But doesn't that seem like a flaw in our economy- No, no, no, no. It's the market- ... that people are compensated differently when they work hard?
Your prompt is if you work hard, you should be able to build wealth. Yes.
I just gave you two ways workers could build wealth if the system wasn't rigged against them.
No, the-- Listen, first of all- Who is it protecting if they don't give out equity?
I, I will tell you right now- Diluting equity hurts you.
Not giving out dividends hurts you. You know, it goes back to the debate California's having with the exodus of all the people have left there because- We're not talking about taxes. No, it's not taxes. We're talking about compensation.
They put minimum wages in place, which we are talking about here.
New York has a high minimum wage, and we haven't lost workers.
So what they have in California, because people can't afford to run the business anymore.
So in the end, what they tried to fix- I'm pretty sure New York City is filled with bodegas who employ people.
We don't have a problem with minimum wage here.
Okay. But the point is, you're talking about trying to advance and create wealth.
Most people in America, there's 120 million people in America right now that do not have any money invested in their own name.
And if we gave them stock in the company they worked for, wouldn't they then have investments?
Why are you asking them to take- Because I'm trying to solve a problem today ... small amounts of savings and put it in the market?
Why are you asking them to take- Because I'm trying to solve a problem today ... small amounts of savings and put it in the market?
Why isn't the company giving them equity in the company they make value for?
Why don't you take your 15% of what you make each week and invest it in every company? Do you know what people are spending?
Where are they going to get 15%? Do you know how much gas has gone up in the last four years? It's gone up 100%.
If I went into your closet, I'd show you 20 or 30- Dude, I've had this jacket for five years.
You're not going to pull the bullshit savings thing on me.
You mean you have no clothes except those?
Right. That's right. That's right. This is the only thing I own.
You're so right, Mr. Wonderful. Thank you for the financial advice. The point is, you have bought a lot of crap you don't need. I really believe that.
You're so right, Mr. Wonderful. Thank you for the financial advice. The point is, you have bought a lot of crap you don't need. I really believe that.
Actually, I'm doing just fine financially.
I'm not here advocating for myself, thankfully. Yeah. I'm not here about that.
I'm here to have a conversation with you about the structure of the economy that is holding people down.
And what frustrates me about you specifically is you have a platform. Yeah.
People listen to you, right? You have a platform. You're here doing podcast after podcast.
You could have gone on CNBC this morning. People listen to you, and you're here bullying a bunch of kids to work harder when you could literally be going toe-to-toe.
I think I'm getting bullied. You could go toe-to-toe with other people in the industry and say, "Hey, the economy is not working for a lot of people.
Maybe we should change that." But you're lecturing us to work harder.
No, I think what I'm saying is factual. I'm telling you- I gave you so many examples of real-life people that are going through struggle, and you're not giving any factual things back.
Well, I'm trying to figure out what you'd like to change.
Would you like the government to tell businesses, "Look, you're going to give more of your profits to the workers"?
Why not? That's basically the minimum wage argument. Why don't we do that?
Well, they've tried. We used to, by the way, in America, have more profit sharing.
If you go back to the '50s, which I think a lot of people view as a very prosperous time in America, for example, General Motors had a profit-sharing agreement with its workers, which is why back then people could have one middle-class job that would provide for a family, a house, going to college,
because we actually had a structure that worked for people. We tried it.
You don't interrupt that, Ronald Reagan. What's the largest state in the country?
It's California. We tried increasing the minimum wage up and up and up and up and up to solve for your problem, and the economy failed. You're talking about the minimum wage. to solve for your problem, and the economy failed. You're talking about the minimum wage.
I'm talking about equity, and I'm talking about dividends.
By the way, you know who agrees with me? Your Shark Tank co-host, Mark Cuban.
Mark Cuban this year said all employees at every company he invested in should get equity. You know how he said that?
Because he understands when that company gets sold, he gets money for his investment, just like you would, but so then would the employees.
The employees would get wealth for the work they did.
Why are you the only one getting wealth?
Hey, listen, I thought when, you know, uh, what happened with the Elon Musk deal, I mean, you know, SpaceX went public, the janitor became a millionaire.
I'm cool with that. Sure. I agree the janitor should become a millionaire, but is that the case universally across the economy? No.
That's what's holding people back, is the system is rigged against them.
You can't do that in every business. You can't give equity to a utility.
Sure, but you could give them dividends. You could share profit.
There's so many vehicles. You want to do it in a startup, an entrepreneurial startup, that's one thing.
The option pools generally are 20%. Yeah.
So if you're in a startup where there's high risk, you get a piece of the deal.
I agree. Right. If the business is 200 years old and it's already owned publicly, you can't just give away the equity. You can give RSUs.
Every public company does that. Again, I'm a software engineer.
Not every public company. If I went to Amazon as a software engineer, I would make 100,000 dollars more at Amazon. Why don't you want to do that?
Because I don't want to work at Amazon. It's a gross company. Ooh.
I kind of like Amazon. But my point is, if I went to Amazon as a software engineer, I get RSUs. I get equity.
If I worked as a warehouse worker, I don't get equity.
You don't want to make 100,000 more? No, I don't want to work at Amazon, but I'm not talking about me.
This isn't about me. This is about the warehouse workers who can't build wealth because the company captures all of their work and stuffs it away in the stock market so you can get rich. Well, wait a second.
I work pretty damn hard to get rich. I'm sure you once did, but now you just go podcast to podcast. You ain't doing shit.
No, I'm still doing a lot of investing. I'm proud of it. Wow, you're investing.
That's so hard. How do you decide what to invest in? What makes you so valuable?
I try and find people like you with a lot of passion, and I think they have a great business plan, and I fund them.
Oh, they have a good business plan. Can I use ChatGPT to analyze their business plan?
What are you bringing to the table? Money.
Oh, thank God. Is there any alternative ways?
Maybe the whole economy is broken because we're stuck with people like you controlling all the money.
Why aren't there alternative forms of investment? I don't control all the money.
I have some. Why isn't the Federal Reserve giving out, like, small business loans?
Why are we dependent on people like you? No, no, you're not.
If I have a good idea, why do I have to go on Shark Tank and beg you to screw me?
Why isn't there alternative vehicles? I love it. You should come on Shark Tank.
Oh, I never will. I don't want to be an entrepreneur, bro. I just want to live.
No, I think you'd be good television. All right. You got it. We're out of time.
Please return to your seat. Thank you.
End of transcript · 1,643 words
TranslateMom transcribes and translates videos from X, TikTok, YouTube and Instagram. Paste a link and you get a page like this one, in your language.