0:00

We heard earlier in the session how much money is being spent by public services on future-proofing their facilities to be in line with the code.

0:08

We also know that many women's services who have been providing trans-inclusive services safely for decades are already incredibly stretched for funds and capacity to provide their vital services, and are now faced with implementing what is felt by many to be an unworkable and discriminatory code.

0:25

How does the panel feel about time and funds potentially being directed away from survivors' immediate needs in order to implement the code, and what provisions are being made to ensure that trans women have the same level and ease of access to survivor services as cis women?

0:41

So, again, I'll just clarify, this is in terms of implementing the code.

0:46

Yeah. So, thank you. Well, I would say that amongst the women's organizations in the network, uh, across Scotland, some of which have now disaffiliated from Rape Crisis Scotland and Scottish Women's Aid, they are absolutely delighted because they were providing women-only services,

1:09

but doing it in fear and feeling under duress that they, that, that funding would be cut either from the government or from the local councils if they said that their services were women-only.

1:23

And I would also say that when you talk about trans women accessing these services, I mean, I think Edinburgh Women's Aid said that over the, over 15 years, they'd had four, and it was only about the advocacy services.

1:38

It was never about accommodation. So, I think you are building something up that is not necessarily an issue.

1:48

If there is an issue with male-on-male violence, and I think there is, I think those services have to be provided separately and with due consideration for the sort of different trauma that happens there.

2:04

Um, Isabel Kerr, who, um, is also on the board of BIROS with me and who ran Glasgow Rape Crisis for many years and kept it women-only, um, she said she was consulted on a project with an LGBT group many years ago to try to get equivalent services,

2:26

and they found the need there was for gay men, actually.

2:29

That was the biggest need. Um, the funding for that was pulled and cut because they wanted these people to go into the women's sector, and that wasn't an appropriate place, and they said at the time it wasn't an appropriate place.

2:42

So, no, okay, so sorry, I'm speaking to the code.

2:44

So, but I'm, I'm trying to say that really the code is only saying what has been known about and, and, uh, for a very long time.

2:54

For a very, very long time, anybody truly working on the front line of women's services would tell you the need to have women-only spaces, and that has always been true, and there were fears of...

3:06

So, I think for many people in the women's sector, it's been a huge relief.

3:11

That doesn't mean you don't provide other services, but you ask the organizations who represent these groups why they're not providing them, frankly.

3:19

Why aren't they using the money that they get from Scottish government to provide them?

3:24

And why was money spent, you're talking about money being spent changing facilities, why was this money spent changing facilities in defiance of the law?

3:34

And yes, I was at the 50th anniversary event for Glasgow Rape Crisis this week.

3:40

They're facing a funding gap. It's disgraceful.

3:42

This parliament says it's interested in misogyny and violence against women.

3:46

Well, there's a great way to spend money.

3:48

What money should not be spent on is court cases trying to disapply this code, as has been done up until now.

3:57

And, and I'll just answer. If people think-

End of transcript · 637 words

iPhone app Translate videos on your iPhone Paste a TikTok, Instagram or X link, add subtitles in your language and save the video to Photos.

Made with TranslateMom

TranslateMom transcribes and translates videos from X, TikTok, YouTube and Instagram. Paste a link and you get a page like this one, in your language.

Transcribed with TranslateMom. Paste any video link to get subtitles and a transcript in your language.

© 2026 TranslateMom · AI video translation and subtitles Transcripts Sources Pricing Legal