Why Engineers Should Question Constraints Before Optimizing
2 min Tech & science
2 min Tech & science
And you, you should actually take the approach that the, the constraints that you are given are guaranteed to be some degree wrong.
Guaranteed to be some degree wrong. Huh.
Uh, 'cause the, the counterpoint would be that they are perfect.
The-- Right, which is never. It's-- Um, as you say, like, what are the-- what's the probability that this is a platonic ideal of the perfect part?
Right. Zero. Zero. Okay? Basically. Yeah. So, you question your constraints.
It does not matter if the person handing you those constraints won a Nobel Prize.
They are-- Even Einstein was wrong some of the time.
Right. So, uh, question your constraints.
This is extremely important. Um, and like an-- I think another thing that, like, if you say, like, what, what are the mistakes that smart engineers make?
Um, like, I think that one of the most-- one of the biggest traps for smart engineers is optimizing a, a thing that shouldn't exist.
Yeah. Um- So they'll just sit there and spin on that thing that's just like, why do we even have this in the first place?
Well, we-- Absolutely. Yeah. So the-- because, um, when, when you go through college, you know, like studying physics and engineering, I studied physics, uh, the-- you have to answer the question that the professor gives you.
Mm-hmm. You don't get to say, "This is the wrong question." Right, right, right. Um- Yeah.
But in reality, uh, we have far more degrees-- When you're in reality or the-- you have all the degrees of freedom of reality.
And so the first thing you should say is, "This question is wrong." Yeah. And that's what you said last year. Yeah.
I mean, you kind of said like, "It took us a long time to frame the question even."
Yes. Because we didn't necessarily know what it was.
It took ages to frame the question. Yeah.
It's just like The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.
Douglas Adams, best philosopher ever. Maybe the-- I think best book in philosophy ever, Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.
Um, this book is so deep, uh, people don't even understand.
Uh, but like in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, the Earth is a giant computer. Right.
And, and, and the Earth, uh, it comes up with the answer 42. Okay. Yeah. Um, and, and to the question, like, so what's the answer to life, the universe, and everything?
Answer is 42. And like, they're like, "What the hell?
That doesn't make any sense." Right. It's like, oh, you-- The really-- The hard part is the question.
Is the question. The answer is the easy part.
You need a much more powerful computer to tell you what the question is. Right.
And this is true. Once-- The point at which you can properly frame the question, the answer is comparatively easy. Right.
End of transcript · 483 words
TranslateMom transcribes and translates videos from X, TikTok, YouTube and Instagram. Paste a link and you get a page like this one, in your language.