Turkey’s EU Membership: Accession Talks and Debate
6 min Machine translated About Türkiye Politics
6 min Machine translated About Türkiye Politics
And thirdly, we have decided to confirm that Turkey is a candidate for membership of the European Union.
The answer the Commission gives today is yes, a positive answer regarding compliance with the criteria and a favorable recommendation to open negotiations.
But this is a qualified yes, accompanied by a series of recommendations concerning the monitoring and assessment of the situation in Turkey and specific recommendations on how to conduct the negotiations.
But these are accession negotiations, and such negotiations must be conducted in good faith, that is, with the intention of bringing them to a successful conclusion.
Uh, that is also undisputed, but of course there is a risk that such a success may not be— Thank you, Chuck.
I've said in the last couple of weeks and months that I was always confident that we would start negotiations on October third, and now you can see that the European Union keeps its word.
Second, I think it's very important to stop the race ahead toward enlargement until Europe has been given new institutions.
And I raise the question of Turkey very clearly.
If I am President of the Republic, I will oppose Turkey's entry into the European Union.
The time has come to tell the Turks “Do we want them or don't we?”
For me, by the way, this is not a question of democracy, it's not at all a question of Muslims or Islam.
It's that Turkey is Asia Minor, It isn't Europe.
And so we must tell the great Turkish people clearly that they are destined to be the heart of the Union for the Mediterranean, but not the EU's heart.
For 40 years, we've let our Turkish friends believe, because you're right, they're a great people and a great civilization, that they belong in the European Union.
We've been making them believe that for 40 years— You saw the great demonstrations for secularism that just took place in Turkey.
But, but, but, ma'am— Let's back this secular, democratic movement.
But even if it's a secular country, it's in Asia Minor.
I won't explain to French schoolchildren that Europe's borders are with Iraq and Syria.
And when we've made Kurdistan a European problem, We won't have progressed.
But we can't admit everyone in Europe as a full member and that's why our shared position is a privileged partnership for Turkey, but no full membership for Turkey.
An open- ended outcome means that the outcome isn't settled yet during the negotiation process.
As I've said several times, I'm skeptical about Turkey becoming a full member, but I want to continue this negotiation process, as we agreed.
When it comes to accession talks with Turkey, we agreed to open Chapter 33 during the Dutch presidency based on the Commission's proposal to be presented in April.
The European Union will have more than 27 members in the years that follow.
All candidate countries have the rule of law, the judiciary and fundamental values as top negotiation priorities.
This rules out Turkey joining the EU in the foreseeable future.
And I hope that we can resume a calm dialogue that will allow us to build a relationship that is essential in my eyes, both for ourselves, for the region and for stability, and that will anchor Turkey in every respect in this dialogue with the European Union.
But it is clear that we must stop pretending that a natural progression toward opening new chapters is possible.
That isn't true. We have repeatedly stated that Türkiye needs to effectively reverse the negative trend in the areas of fundamental rights and the rule of law.
We have conveyed the message, too, in various bilateral meetings with Turkish authorities, and we have taken concrete measures.
In 2018, the European Council took the extraordinary step of putting the negotiations on Türkiye's EU candidacy at an effective standstill.
Um, I personally, and the German government, see Turkey as closely aligned with the European Union.
We want to continue, um, paving the way to Europe, uh, further.
The— The path to the European Union is a path that leads through compliance with the Copenhagen criteria.
Um, decisions have been made in Turkey that, um, still do not meet the standards with regard to the rule of law and democracy, as we understand them from the European perspective.
Yes, I sometimes think, If I look back in 20 or 10 years, perhaps and we don't succeed, in completing the European continent as the European Union, then it's not as if it wouldn't matter, and nothing would have happened,
but then these would be our direct neighbors, influenced by Russia, Turkey, or China, and certainly difficult for us.
And that's why I think it's in our strategic interest to expand the European Union.
Can an authoritarian country be a candidate for the European Union?
Apparently yes, but an authoritarian country will never be a member, because this is still a club of mature democracies and we want it to stay that way.
Türkiye is a key partner, a NATO ally, and a candidate country.
Without serious progress on the rule of law, fundamental rights, and democracy, there are no prospects to resume accession negotiations.
End of transcript · 866 words · machine translated
And thirdly, we have decided to confirm that Turkey is a candidate for membership of the European Union.
La risposta che la Commissione dà oggi è un sì, una risposta positiva sul rispetto dei criteri e una raccomandazione favorevole all'apertura dei negoziati.
Si tratta però di un sì qualificato, accompagnato da una serie di raccomandazioni per quanto riguarda il controllo e la verifica della situazione in Turchia e da raccomandazioni specifiche sul modo di condurre i negoziati.
Sondern es geht um Beitrittsverhandlungen und solche Verhandlungen müssen bona fide geführt werden, das heißt in der Absicht, sie auch zum Erfolg zu führen.
Äh, das ist auch unbestritten, aber selbstverständlich besteht das Risiko, dass ein solcher Erfolg nicht ein- Thank you, Chuck.
I've said in the last couple of weeks and months that I was always confident that we start the negotiations on the 3rd of October, and now you can see that the European Union sticks to its word.
Deuxième point, je crois très important d'arrêter la course en avant vers l'élargissement tant qu'on n'a pas doté l'Europe de nouvelles institutions.
Et je pose très clairement la question de la Turquie.
Si je suis président de la République, je m'opposerai à l'entrée de la Turquie dans l'Union européenne.
Il est quand même venu le temps de dire aux Turcs : « Est-ce qu'on en veut ou est-ce qu'on n'en veut pas ? » Pour moi, d'ailleurs, ce n'est pas une question de démocratie, ce n'est pas du tout une question de musulmans ou d'islam.
C'est que la Turquie, c'est l'Asie mineure, ce n'est pas l'Europe.
Et donc il faut dire clairement à ce grand peuple qu'est la Turquie qu'ils ont vocation à être le cœur de l'Union de la Méditerranée, mais pas le cœur de l'Union européenne.
Depuis 40 ans, on laisse à croire à nos amis turcs, car vous avez raison, c'est un grand peuple et une grande civilisation, qu'ils ont leur place en Union européenne.
Ça fait 40 ans qu'on leur fait croire- Vous avez vu les grandes manifestations pour la laïcité qui viennent d'avoir lieu en Turquie.
Mais, mais, mais madame- Aidons ce mouvement laïque et démocratique.
Mais quand bien même c'est un pays laïque, il est en Asie mineure.
Je n'expliquerai pas aux écoliers français que les frontières de l'Europe sont avec l'Irak et la Syrie.
Et quand on aura fait du Kurdistan un problème européen, on n'aura pas fait avancer les choses.
Aber wir können nicht jeden in Europa aufnehmen als Vollmitglied und deshalb heißt unsere gemeinsame Position privilegierte Partnerschaft für die Türkei, aber keine volle Mitgliedschaft der Türkei.
Ergebnis offen heißt, dass das Ergebnis während des Verhandlungsprozesses noch nicht feststeht.
Ich hab ja schon öfter gesagt, dass ich eine Skepsis gegenüber einer Vollmitgliedschaft der Türkei habe, aber ich möchte diesen Verhandlungsprozess weiterführen, so wie wir es abgemacht haben.
When it comes to accession talks with Turkey, we agreed to open chapter 33 during the Dutch presidency based on the Commission's proposal to be presented in April.
Die Europäische Union wird in den darauffolgenden Jahren mehr als 27 Mitglieder zählen.
Bei allen Beitrittsländern haben Rechtsstaatlichkeit, Justiz und Grundwerte oberste Verhandlungspriorität.
Das schließt eine EU-Mitgliedschaft der Türkei in absehbarer Zeit aus.
Et je souhaite que nous puissions reprendre un dialogue apaisé qui permette de construire une relation qui est essentielle à mes yeux, à la fois pour nous-mêmes, pour la région et la stabilité, qui ancre à tous égards la Turquie dans ce dialogue avec l'Union européenne.
Mais il est évident que nous devons sortir d'une hypocrisie qui consisterait à penser qu'une progression naturelle vers l'ouverture de nouveaux chapitres est possible.
Ça n'est pas vrai. We have repeatedly stated that Türkiye needs to effectively reverse the negative trend in the areas of fundamental rights and rule of law.
We have passed the message also in various bilateral meetings with Turkish authorities, and we have taken concrete measures.
In 2018, the European Council took the extraordinary step of putting the negotiations on Türkiye's candidacy to the EU at an effective standstill.
Ähm, ich sehe persönlich und die Bundesregierung sieht die Türkei eng an der Seite der Europäischen Union.
Wir wollen den Weg, äh, nach Europa, äh, weiter ebnen.
Die-- Der Weg in die Europäische Union ist ein Weg, der über die Einhaltung der Kopenhagener Kriterien führt.
Ähm, es sind, äh, in der Türkei Entscheidungen getroffen worden, die, ähm, noch nicht den Ansprüchen genügen im Hinblick auf Rechtsstaatlichkeit und Demokratie, so wie wir sie aus der europäischen Sicht, äh, verstehen.
Ja, ich denk manchmal, wenn ich in 20 Jahren oder 10 Jahren vielleicht zurückschaue und es gelingt uns nicht, den europäischen Kontinent zu vervollständigen als Europäische Union, dann ist es nicht so, dass das nichts weiter ausmacht und da nichts passiert wäre,
sondern dann sind diese unsere direkten Nachbarn russisch beeinflusst oder türkisch beeinflusst oder chinesisch beeinflusst, aber auf jeden Fall schwierig für uns.
Und deshalb glaub ich, dass es in unserem strategischen Interesse ist, die Europäische Union zu erweitern.
¿Puede un país autoritario ser candidato a la Unión Europea?
Aparentemente sí, pero un país autoritario nunca será miembro, porque este es todavía un club de democracias maduras y queremos que lo siga siendo.
Türkiye is a key partner, a NATO ally, and a candidate country.
Without serious progress on the rule of law, fundamental rights, and democracy, there are no prospects to resume accession negotiations.
TranslateMom transcribes and translates videos from X, TikTok, YouTube and Instagram. Paste a link and you get a page like this one, in your language.